Menu
close

Education Commission of the States is the trusted source for comprehensive knowledge and unbiased resources on education policy issues ranging from early learning through postsecondary education.

Subscribe

Subscribe to our publications and stay informed.

Request Assistance

Need more information? Contact one of our policy experts.

50-State Comparison: Teacher Recruitment and Retention

Schools continue to face specific and persistent teacher shortages in certain subjects, such as upper-level math and special education, and in certain schools, including historically under-resourced schools and rural schools. The current teacher workforce also has a shortage of teachers of color, who have a positive impact on student outcomes and school climate. These shortages are more likely to impact schools that serve students in rural and urban areas, linguistically diverse students, students identified for special education and students of color. Shortages contribute to students being taught by inexperienced or out-of-field teachers and they can be financially costly for schools and districts. Declining participation in teacher preparation programs, coupled with high turnover in the profession, suggests that a comprehensive approach that accounts for each stage of the teacher pipeline is necessary to recruit and retain effective teachers.

Teacher Pipeline

This resource compiles state-specific data related to teacher shortages and provides a national comparison of state policies to recruit and retain teachers across the teacher pipeline. The 50-State Comparison includes state policies relevant to each stage of the pipeline with separate sections on state teacher workforce data and financial incentives, which are important state policy levers at every stage of the pipeline.

Click on a question below to see data for all states. To view a specific state’s approach, go to the State Profiles page.

50-State Comparison

1. Has the state published state-specific teacher shortage data within the past five years? Does the state disaggregate teacher shortage data by race and/or ethnicity?

 

2. Has the state published educator equity gap data that is more recent than what was submitted in the Educator Equity Plan and/or ESSA State Plan?

 

3. Has the state administered a statewide teacher retention or working conditions survey within the past five years?

4. Does the state offer a pathway, program or incentive through statute or regulation to recruit high school students into the teaching profession?

 

5. Does the state offer a pathway, program or incentive through statute or regulation to recruit paraprofessionals into the teaching profession?

 

6. Does the state create or support teacher residency programs through statute or regulation?

7. Does the state require induction and mentoring support for new teachers? If so, what is the required length?

 

8. Does the state require or encourage reduced teaching loads for new and/or mentor teachers?

 

9. Does the state set minimum qualifications for mentor teachers?

10. Does the state require that an established portion of a teacher's workday/work week be designated exclusively for teacher planning?

 

11. Does the state require certain measures for teacher evaluations in statute or regulation?

 

12. Does the state have a licensure system that allows teachers to advance beyond a standard professional license?

 

13. Does the state offer a teacher leader license or endorsement?

 

14. Has the state adopted teacher leader standards?

15. Does statute establish requirements for minimum teacher pay?

 

16. Does statute define at least one statewide scholarship or grant program to help recruit teachers for underserved schools and/or shortage subject areas?

 

17. Does statute define at least one statewide loan forgiveness program to help recruit teachers for underserved schools and/or shortage subject areas?

 

18. Does statute require, or explicitly encourage, additional pay for teachers who work in underserved schools and/or shortage subject areas?

 

19. Does statute define at least one statewide financial incentive program for teachers of color?

 

20. Does the state require or provide additional pay for teachers who obtain advanced licensure?

 

21. Does the state require or provide additional pay for teachers who obtain National Board Certification?

Key Takeaways

  • Forty states and the District of Columbia have published teacher shortage data in the past five years.
  • Thirty-eight states and the District of Columbia have released educator equity gap data since they originally submitted their ESSA plans.
  • Twenty-seven states and the District of Columbia have conducted a statewide teacher working conditions survey in the past five years. Some states conduct a survey annually.
  • States are creating pathways, programs and/or incentives to recruit high school students and/or paraprofessionals into the teaching profession. Thirty-two states offer pathways for high school students, while 25 states and the District of Columbia offer one for paraprofessionals.
  • Twenty-one states and the District of Columbia have created or supported teacher residencies in state policy. Thirty-one states require induction and mentoring support for new teachers in statute or regulation. Thirty-five states set minimum qualifications for teachers serving as mentors.
  • Thirty-seven states and the District of Columbia have at least one scholarship program for teachers who commit to teach in underserved schools or shortage subject areas and 25 states have a loan forgiveness program for the same purpose.
  • Fourteen states have established incentives for teachers of color in state policy. Another 13 states either prioritize teachers of color in existing scholarship or loan forgiveness programs or provide support to teacher preparation programs in recruiting teachers of color.

Published:

Dec. 1, 2022

Education Level:

Resource Type:

More on This Issue

Copyright 2025 / Education Commission of the States. All rights reserved.

chevron-downarrow-rightmenu-circlecross-circle